Steve Schmidt · Originally sent November 11, 2026

YOUR GOOGLE
PROFILE
LOOKS CLOSED.

Give your business the stranger test.

Editorial illustration of a busy Sioux Falls repair shop beside a phone listing marked closed. Headline: Your Google profile looks closed.

You’re open.

The coffee is terrible. The phone is ringing. Somebody has already asked where the extension cord went.

But on a customer’s phone, your business looks like a place that used to exist.

Last photo? A logo.

Hours? A suggestion.

Website button? Sends them on a scavenger hunt.

Then we all get together and blame the algorithm. Lovely meeting. Same time next month?

Before you spend another dollar getting found, look at what people find.

Give your business the stranger test

Hand your phone to someone who doesn’t work for you. Ask them to find your business and answer three questions.

“Can you help me?”

“Are you open when I need you?”

“What do I do next?”

Let them talk. Resist the urge to reach across the table and explain where you hid the answer. Your customers don’t come with an owner leaning over their shoulder.

Google’s own guidance says local ranking considers relevance, distance and prominence. Complete information helps Google understand what you do. Review activity and links also contribute to prominence. Your position can change with where the searcher is standing. A tidy profile gives you a stronger starting point. Google’s local ranking guidance

CAN THEY TELL. YOU’RE OPEN?. CAN YOU HELP ME?. Name the services you actually provide.. WHEN ARE YOU OPEN?. Confirm holiday hours and emergency coverage.. WHAT DO I DO NEXT?. Test the phone and the service-page link.. A stranger should be able to answer all three.

Fix the Thanksgiving question

If you’re closed Thursday, say so. If you’re doing emergency work, tell customers what that means and who answers. A promise of “24/7 service” deserves a test call.

In Google Business Profile, open Edit profile, then Hours, then Special hours. Confirm Thanksgiving and Friday. Google recommends confirming holiday hours even when you keep your normal schedule. Check the public profile afterward. Google’s special-hours instructions

A salon’s Friday hours and an HVAC shop’s emergency coverage answer different questions. Spell yours out. If callers can leave messages while the shop is closed, tell them when a person will respond.

Put a job where the logo is

A homeowner with a ruined door wants to know whether anybody can save it. Alex Johnson at Advanced Laser Restoration gives that question something to look at. The old finish, the restored wood, the work on video, and a quiz to explore fit.

I like that sequence because each piece earns the next click. Find one job you can show that clearly. An auto shop can show what was worn and how the technician found it. A groomer can show the finished work with the owner’s permission. A clinic can explain the steps to a first visit without exposing a patient. The Sioux Falls door example

Here’s a demonstration to try with your own work. Pick three photos. Write what the customer asked, what you checked, and what happened. An AI writing tool can help trim the explanation. Have the person who did the work verify every sentence before it goes up. Your robot did not crawl under that sink.

YOUR LOGO CAN’T. FIX MY DOOR.. THE QUESTION. What was the customer trying to solve?. THE WORK. Show the job and explain what you checked.. THE NEXT STEP. Give the reader a clear way to explore fit.. Use a real job and photos you have permission to share.

Ask for the review after the work

Give real customers an easy way to describe their experience. Use the same neutral request across completed jobs. My starting line would be, “Would you share an honest review of your experience? Here’s the link.”

Google prohibits paying for reviews or offering a discount in exchange. Ask consistently and let the customer choose what to say. Google review guidance

Count what happened after the tap

Google’s Calls metric counts taps on the call button. Compare it with your actual call records and bookings. Website clicks are another step to follow. If someone hits the site and can’t find the service they searched for, that’s work for the website. Google’s performance definitions

CHECK THE HOURS.. THEN THE PHONE.. SPECIAL HOURS. Set Thursday and Friday accurately.. CALL BUTTON. Call your number and follow the actual handoff.. WEBSITE BUTTON. Check that it leads to the service a buyer needs.. Google Calls counts call-button taps. Verify real calls too.

Run the stranger test. Confirm the holiday hours. Check the phone and website button. Put one real job in front of the next person searching.

Your profile ought to look like somebody still cares what happens here.

God first. Always.

— Steve